Student of the Year: A Deep Dive into Karan Johar's High School Drama

Introduction

"Student of the Year" is a 2012 Indian Hindi-language romantic comedy-drama film directed by Karan Johar. The film marked the acting debuts of Sidharth Malhotra, Alia Bhatt, and Varun Dhawan. The movie revolves around the competition between students at St. Teresa's College. The film explores themes of friendship, love, competition, and the pressures of academic life.

Synopsis

The film begins with several alumni reminiscing about their final year at St. Theresa's College and the events that shaped their lives. The story unfolds as Sudo (Kayoze Irani) begins the story, by revisiting the past. The film introduces us to the stereotypical ‘high school kids’. guy, the geek, the tomboy, the funny one and of course the sweet guy. The film is based around the core idea of “who gets the girl” and “who’ll win the trophy”.

At the elite St. Teresa's College, Rohan Nanda (Varun Dhawan) is a wealthy, popular student and the younger son of business magnate Ashok Nanda. While Rohan aspires to be a musician, his father wants him to follow in the footsteps of his elder brother, Ajay, and join the family business. Abhimanyu "Abhi" Singh (Sidharth Malhotra), a new student from a modest background, transfers to St. Teresa’s on scholarship. Ambitious and driven, Abhi idolizes Ashok and sees success at St. Teresa’s as a path to upward mobility.

Initially at odds with Ro, he earns his respect after a football match, and the two develop a close friendship. Abhi is introduced to Shanaya (Alia Bhatt), with Ro warning him not to pursue her. Though Abhi assures him otherwise, he gradually finds himself drawn to her. During Ajay’s wedding, Shanaya catches Ro flirting with Tanya and, feeling betrayed, attempts to make him jealous by drawing closer to Abhi. Although hesitant at first, Abhi begins to reciprocate her feelings.

The trio advances through the initial rounds of the Student of the Year competition. However, Abhi's grandmother, his only living family, passes away before the dance competition; in a moment of grief, Abhi and Shanaya share a kiss, which Ro witnesses, leading to a confrontation that fractures their friendship. Simultaneously, Shanaya falls out with her best friend Shruti, while Ro parts ways with his longtime friend Jeet Khurana.

The concluding triathlon event tests swimming, cycling, and running. Abhi, leading the race, deliberately slows down in the final stretch, allowing Rohan to win. However, Ro declines the trophy, stating that he does not wish to accept it. Their friend Kaizad "Sudo" Sodabottleopenerwala criticizes the competition, blaming it for breaking friendships and perpetuating favoritism, which prompts Yogi to retire.

A decade later, a terminally ill Yogi requests a reunion with his former students. Ro, now a rock musician, and Abhi, an investment banker now married to Shanaya, return to meet him. The reunion triggers unresolved tensions between Ro and Abhi, particularly over the events of the competition. During a heated exchange, Abhi reveals he lost the triathlon intentionally after noticing Ashok's satisfaction with Ro's defeat. Their argument gives way to reconciliation, rekindling their friendship. Yogi dies shortly after, content at having reunited his students.

Themes and Analysis

Friendship and Competition

"Student of the Year" explores the complexities of friendship in the face of intense competition. The rivalry between Abhi and Rohan is central to the plot, highlighting how ambition and the desire for success can strain even the strongest bonds. The film questions whether a trophy is more valuable than friendship, a theme underscored by Sudo's powerful dialogue criticizing the competition for breaking friendships.

Love and Betrayal

The love triangle between Abhi, Rohan, and Shanaya adds another layer of complexity to the narrative. Shanaya's initial attraction to Rohan and her subsequent involvement with Abhi create tension and betrayal. The film examines how jealousy and miscommunication can lead to misunderstandings and fractured relationships.

Family Pressures and Expectations

The film also touches on the pressures faced by young people from their families. Rohan's struggle to balance his passion for music with his father's expectations to join the family business reflects a common conflict in many Indian families. The cold tension between Rohan and his father, contrasted with his mother's passive role, highlights traditional family dynamics in India.

Read also: Guide to UC Davis Student Housing

Questioning the Education System

"Student of the Year" subtly critiques the education system and the emphasis on competition. The film questions the value of labeling one student as "the best" and suggests that such competitions can create "monsters instead of humans." It challenges the notion that winning a gold medal is more important than fostering genuine friendships and personal growth.

LGBT Themes

Some viewers have interpreted subtle LGBT themes in the film, particularly in the relationship between Abhi and Rohan. Certain scenes, such as their dance-off, lingering touches, and the bridal-style carry, have been interpreted as hinting at a deeper connection between the two male characters. While not explicitly stated, these moments add an intriguing layer to their relationship.

Production

Directed by Karan Johar, written by Rensil D'Silva, and produced by Hiroo Yash Johar and Gauri Khan under the banners of Dharma Productions and Red Chillies Entertainment. The film stars debutantes Sidharth Malhotra, Varun Dhawan, and Alia Bhatt, with supporting performances from Rishi Kapoor, Ronit Roy, Sahil Anand, Manjot Singh, Ram Kapoor, Farida Jalal, Manasi Rachh, Sana Saeed, and Kayoze Irani.

On 5 January 2011, director Karan Johar and presenter Shah Rukh Khan shared the first-look poster of Student of the Year on social media, officially announcing the project. Malhotra and Dhawan had earlier worked as assistant directors on Johar's My Name Is Khan (2010). Notably, Student of the Year became Johar's first directorial venture without Shah Rukh Khan in the lead role.

Principal photography took place primarily in Dehradun, with scenes filmed at the Forest Research Institute and Kasiga School, which served as the exterior for the fictional St. Teresa's College. Additional sequences were shot in Srinagar, including hospital scenes filmed outside The Lalit Grand Palace. Parts of the film were also shot in Thailand.

Read also: Investigating the Death at Purdue

Marketing

As part of its promotional strategy, the film employed contest-based marketing targeting the youth demographic. Tata Motors served as the on-ground promotion partner and launched the "Nano Student of the Year" contest, which evaluated students across four categories: academics, culture, sports, and social life. The satellite rights for Student of the Year were bundled with Yeh Jawaani Hai Deewani and sold to Sony Entertainment Television for ₹50 crore (US$5.9 million). The music rights were acquired by Sony Music for ₹7 crore (US$830,000).

Reception

Upon its release on 19 October 2012, "Student of the Year" received mixed reviews from critics. While it was praised for its performances, visuals, direction, and music, some criticism was directed at its writing and narrative depth. Despite skepticism surrounding its high budget and the absence of established stars, Student of the Year performed well at the box office.

Critical Response

Critics had mixed reactions to the film. Some praised the performances of the debutantes and the film's visual appeal, while others criticized the storyline for being clichéd and lacking depth.

Box Office Performance

Despite mixed reviews, "Student of the Year" performed well at the box office, particularly in multiplexes. The film's success was attributed to its appeal to young audiences and its strong marketing campaign.

Music

The film's soundtrack was composed by Vishal-Shekhar, with lyrics written by Anvita Dutt. The music rights were acquired by Sony Music for ₹7 crore (US$830,000).

Awards and Nominations

At the 58th Filmfare Awards, the film earned four nominations, including Best Male Debut (Malhotra and Dhawan) and Best Female Debut (Bhatt), and won the R. D. Burman Award for New Music Talent (Neeti Mohan for "Ishq Wala Love").

tags: #student #of #the #year #hindi #full