Proposed DHS Rule Changes Impacting International Students: An In-Depth Analysis

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has unveiled a proposed rule that could significantly alter the landscape for international students and exchange visitors in the United States. This proposal, currently under review, aims to replace the existing "duration of status" (D/S) policy with a fixed period of stay, introducing new requirements and restrictions for F-1 and J-1 nonimmigrants. This article delves into the details of the proposed rule, its potential implications, and the ongoing discussions surrounding it.

Understanding the "Duration of Status" Policy

For over three decades, the D/S policy has allowed international students and exchange visitors to remain in the U.S. for the duration of their academic programs or work assignments, provided they maintain good academic and legal standing. Under this system, a student's I-94 and passport stamp indicate "F-1 or J-1 D/S" rather than a specific "admit until" date. This eliminates the need for students to repeatedly apply for extensions as long as they are making satisfactory progress toward their educational goals. Extensions beyond the original program's end date are typically approved by designated officials at the student's institution.

Key Proposed Changes to Student Visa Regulations

The proposed rule seeks to eliminate D/S and introduce a fixed admission period for F and J nonimmigrants. The key proposed changes include:

Fixed Admission Periods

Under the proposed rule, individuals in F or J status would be admitted until the program end date listed on their I-20 or DS-2019, with a maximum stay of four years, plus a 30-day grace period after program completion. Those needing more time to complete their studies, change programs, or pursue Optional Practical Training (OPT) or Academic Training would be required to file Form I-539, Application to Extend/Change Nonimmigrant Status (EOS), with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) before their authorized stay expires.

Shortened Grace Period

The current 60-day grace period for F-1 students would be reduced to 30 days, aligning with the grace period currently in place for J status holders. This shortened period could put additional pressure on students to finalize their plans after completing their programs.

Restrictions on Program Changes

The proposed rule introduces restrictions on program changes for F-1 students. Undergraduate students would be prohibited from changing programs, majors, or educational levels during their first academic year. Graduate-level F-1 students would be prohibited from changing programs at any point during their studies.

Level Restrictions

International students who complete a program at a specific academic level would not be eligible to start a new program at the same or lower academic level under F-1 status. This restriction could limit opportunities for students seeking further education in related fields.

Transfer Limitations

F-1 students would generally not be permitted to transfer to another school until completing one academic year at the institution that issued their initial I-20, unless granted an exception by the Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP).

Travel While EOS Is Pending

F and J individuals with a pending EOS application may be readmitted under two scenarios: for the original authorized period (if the EOS remains active) or for the requested extended period (in which case the EOS application is considered abandoned).

Transition Provisions

The proposed rule includes complex transition measures for individuals admitted under D/S before the effective date. Further guidance on these provisions is expected as it becomes available.

Read also: Guide to UC Davis Student Housing

Accrual of Unlawful Presence

Under the proposed rule, individuals who do not file an EOS on time or fail to depart by the end of their authorized stay would begin accruing unlawful presence immediately. This differs from the current policy, under which D/S holders generally do not accrue unlawful presence until a formal finding of a status violation by USCIS or an immigration judge.

Extension of Stay Conditions

The proposed rule outlines three acceptable reasons for F-1 students to request an extension of stay beyond the end date of their academic program:

Compelling academic reasons, such as the desire to pursue an alternative or more specialized course of study.
A documented illness or medical condition.
Exceptional circumstances beyond the student’s control.

Work Authorization

F-1 students with employment authorization would be eligible for an automatic extension of their work authorization for up to 240 days based on a showing of severe economic hardship resulting from emergent circumstances, provided the extension of status application was timely filed. F-1 students whose applications for post-completion optional practical training (OPT) or STEM-OPT employment authorization are ultimately approved would be authorized to remain in the United States for the validity of their employment authorization document (EAD), plus a sixty-day grace period.

Rationale Behind the Proposed Rule

DHS states that its proposed rule aims to create consistency in periods of admission across nonimmigrant classifications, enhance DHS oversight, and eliminate fraud. The agency believes that replacing the D/S framework with a fixed period of stay will improve monitoring and compliance among foreign students and exchange visitors.

Concerns and Criticisms

The proposed rule has faced significant criticism from higher education institutions and international student advocacy groups. Concerns include:

Read also: Investigating the Death at Purdue

Impact on Academic Pursuits: The four-year admission cap may not be sufficient for students pursuing longer degree programs, such as PhDs or joint degrees. Requiring students to apply for extensions could create unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles and uncertainty.
Restrictions on Flexibility: The limitations on program changes and transfers could hinder students' academic progress and limit their ability to explore different fields of study.
Potential for Backlogs: The new EOS process could create significant backlogs, potentially delaying students' ability to continue their studies or pursue employment opportunities.
Competitiveness: The proposed rule could make the U.S. less attractive to international students, potentially harming the higher education sector's ability to attract global talent.
Data Concerns: Critics argue that the proposed rule is based on flawed data and attempts to address problems that do not exist within the current system.

The Visa Application Process: A General Overview

For individuals seeking to study in the United States, understanding the visa application process is crucial. Generally, foreign nationals must first obtain a student visa (F or M visa) to travel to the U.S. for academic or vocational studies. It is important to note that studying on a visitor (B) visa is generally not permitted, unless the study is recreational and non-credit bearing.

The application process involves several steps:

Apply to a SEVP-approved School: The first step is to apply to and be accepted by a school in the U.S. that is approved by the Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP).
Receive Form I-20: Once accepted, the school will register the student in the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) and issue a Form I-20, Certificate of Eligibility for Nonimmigrant Student Status.
Pay the SEVIS Fee: The student must pay the SEVIS I-901 fee before the visa interview.
Apply for a Visa: The student must then apply for a visa at a U.S. Embassy or Consulate. This involves completing the online Nonimmigrant Visa Application, Form DS-160, and uploading a photo.
Attend an Interview: In most cases, an interview is required. The interview helps the consular officer determine whether the applicant is qualified to receive a student visa.
Provide Required Documents: Applicants must provide a passport valid for travel to the United States, the Form I-20, and any other required documents.

Important Considerations

Student visas for new students can be issued up to 365 days before the start date of a course of study.
Students on F or M visas are not permitted to enter the United States earlier than 30 days before the start date of their program.
A visa does not guarantee entry into the United States. Upon arrival at a U.S. port-of-entry, an immigration officer will determine whether to grant admission.
Failure to depart the United States on time will result in being out of status and may affect future visa eligibility.

The Public Comment Period and What's Next

The proposed rule was published in August, initiating a mandatory public comment period. The public comment period ended September 29, 2025. During this time, organizations and individuals were able to submit their feedback on the proposed changes. DHS will review these comments and may revise the rule before publishing a final version in the Federal Register with a specified effective date. It's important to remember that this is a proposed rule and is not currently in effect.

Staying Informed

International students and exchange visitors should stay informed about the proposed rule and its potential implications. Resources such as International Services alerts and the Executive Orders site can provide up-to-date guidance. It's also advisable to reach out to international student services at your institution for support and clarification.

tags: #dhs #student #visa #restriction #proposal #details