Navigating Uncertainty: Unemployment Risk Factors for Indian Students on OPT Amidst Shifting U.S. Immigration Policies

For Indian students pursuing higher education in the United States, the Optional Practical Training (OPT) program represents a crucial bridge between academic studies and professional careers. OPT allows F-1 international students to work for up to 12 months in a field related to their major. STEM OPT provides an additional 24 months for graduates in science, technology, engineering, and math disciplines. According to data from the Institute of International Education, over 240,000 students participated in OPT and STEM OPT during the 2023-2024 academic year. However, this pathway is increasingly fraught with uncertainty, particularly concerning potential unemployment risks stemming from evolving U.S. immigration policies. This article delves into the various factors that contribute to this risk, offering insights and strategies for Indian students to navigate this complex landscape.

The Looming Shadow of Policy Changes

The potential return of Donald Trump to the White House introduces significant uncertainty for international students, particularly concerning the OPT program and student visa durations. In 2017, during the early months of Trump's presidency, uncertainty for international students was palpable. Campuses reported a decline in international enrollments. For instance, the Illinois Institute of Technology, where nearly half of the students were international, experienced a 25% decline in international enrollments between 2016 and 2018.

Potential Restrictions on OPT and STEM Extensions

STEM students (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) benefit from a two-year extension, giving them a total of three years to gain work experience. However, during Trump’s first term, Stephen Miller, a senior advisor, attempted to restrict OPT and eliminate the STEM extension. With Trump's potential return to office, these policies could be revisited, as Miller’s influence on immigration policy is likely to resurface.

Shortening of Student Visa Durations

In 2020, the Trump administration proposed limiting student visa durations to four years, and in some cases, just two years. Rajiv S. Khanna, an Arlington-based immigration attorney, commented on the proposal, saying, “For Indian and other international students, the proposed fixed tenure creates a problem. A four-year cap is definitely shorter than a PhD or even a bachelor’s degree course, as students may opt for an extra semester." This visa limitation proposal caused widespread concern. Currently, international students can typically remain in the U.S. as long as they maintain their student status, thanks to the "duration of status" policy, which provides flexibility without a set expiration.

Increased Scrutiny and Administrative Challenges

Under the Trump administration, international students may face increased application scrutiny, which often involves additional interviews, extended background checks, and closer examination of supporting documents. For many students, these delays disrupt academic schedules, travel plans, and internship opportunities, while employers face challenges in onboarding international talent in a timely manner. Additionally, during his last term, processing times for visa applications have significantly lengthened due to heightened scrutiny and resource constraints under stricter immigration policies.

Higher H-1B Visa Denials and Requests for Evidence

Trump’s previous term substantially increased H-1B visa denials and Requests for Evidence (RFEs). From 2016 to 2020, H-1B denial rates rose to an average of 18%, compared to 3.2% under the Biden administration. The rate of RFEs also tripled under Trump, peaking at 34%. The limited availability of H-1B visas-currently with a selection rate of about 25%-creates significant uncertainty.

Potential Restrictions on H-4 Visa Holders

H-4 visa holders (spouses of H-1B workers) also face potential restrictions. The Obama-era rule allowing H-4 spouses to work was targeted for elimination by Trump officials, though it wasn’t ultimately rescinded.

Navigating the Legal Landscape: Compliance and Reporting

Strict adherence to immigration rules is paramount for international students. The case of a student denied citizenship, reportedly due to past misuse of an F-1 visa, underscores the importance of adhering strictly to immigration rules.

Importance of Reporting OPT Employment

A recent incident involving OPT students receiving letters from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) highlights the critical need for compliance. The letter advises students that they’ve “been participating in OPT for more than 90 days but have not reported any employer information,” and that if their SEVIS record is not updated within 15 days of the notice, their status will be terminated.

Joann Ng Hartmann, NAFSA senior impact officer, explained, “To most it’s just a reminder that - more than ever, given a hostile administration - students need to comply with all rules and report OPT employment so they are not considered to have accrued ‘unemployment time’ that could result in a termination of their OPT and status.”

Matthew Kolodziej, immigration practice partner at Jia Law Group, noted, “It is widely expected that the actual number is significantly higher as the enforcement effort continues to expand.”

During the administration’s recent string of F-1 SEVIS terminations, most students and colleges were unaware of the change in status until they logged onto their SEVIS portal, with Jia Law Group now urging all F-1 and OPT students to proactively check their records.

Understanding "Unemployment Time"

International students on OPT are allowed a limited period of unemployment. Exceeding this period can lead to termination of their OPT and subsequent loss of legal status.

Alternative Pathways to Maintain Legal Status

For students navigating this challenging landscape, finding ways to remain legally employed is essential.

Day 1 CPT Programs

One option for international students to maintain legal employment status while continuing their studies is Day 1 CPT. Day 1 CPT programs allow students to work in their field of study from the start of their program, providing immediate work authorization.

Read also: CGPA to GPA Guide

Flexible Program Structure

Day 1 CPT programs are often offered by hybrid or executive programs, designed for students who wish to balance work and study. While Day 1 CPT is a valuable option, students should carefully choose accredited institutions and ensure their programs comply with F-1 regulations to avoid immigration issues.

EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program

For students looking to escape the uncertainties of the H-1B visa program and a seemingly unending wait for permanent resident status, the EB-5 program presents a unique and faster alternative for transitioning to permanent residency. The U.S. government created the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program in 1990 to support the economy by creating jobs through foreign investment.

Investment Requirements

To qualify for the EB-5 visa, applicants must make a minimum investment of $800,000 for projects located in designated rural areas or high-unemployment regions, known as targeted employment areas (TEAs). For non-TEA projects, the minimum standard investment is $1,050,000.

Investment Options

EB-5 applicants have two investment options: They can either invest directly into a new commercial enterprise (NCE) or indirectly through a government-approved EB-5 regional center. Regional centers are entities that pool investments from multiple investors into larger development projects. They aim to promote economic growth, improve regional productivity, and create jobs in targeted areas. Most investors prefer the regional center investment route due to several advantages of this model, the most important being the ease of meeting the job creation requirements of the EB-5 program.

Application Process

After selecting a project and making the required investment, investors must submit the EB-5 petition (Form I-526E) to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to demonstrate eligibility, including proof of the investment and job creation plan. Once the petition is approved, the investor and their eligible family members can apply for a two-year conditional Green Card.

Benefits of the EB-5 Visa

One EB-5 investment can support the Green Card applications of the main investor, their spouse, and all unmarried children under 21.
Unlike the H-1B visa, the EB-5 program does not use a lottery. It also avoids the long Green Card wait times that Indian nationals face in other categories.
Students with Green Cards do not need employer sponsorship. They can work for any company, start a business, and even take unpaid internships without risking their immigration status.
Green Card holders qualify as domestic students, which can significantly reduce tuition costs at public universities and colleges. They also become eligible for financial aid and scholarships that are usually unavailable to international students.
Students on F-1 or H-1B visas often face stress from changing rules, job loss, or visa renewals.
Green Card holders have access to the U.S. healthcare system.

Concurrent Filing

For international students on an F-1 visa, an excellent provision called EB-5 concurrent filing enables them to access Green Card benefits soon after they file their EB-5 petition-even before it is approved. Introduced under the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 (RIA), concurrent filing allows EB-5 applicants already in the United States on a valid nonimmigrant visa to file their adjustment of status application (Form I-485) simultaneously with the I-526E petition. Once the I-485 application is filed, students can continue to stay in the United States legally on a “pending adjustment” status while their application is processed. They also become eligible to apply for employment authorization (EAD) and advance parole (AP), which could be approved in as little as 30 days. This way, they can continue to live, study, work, and travel without any restrictions imposed by the F-1 visa while they wait for Green Card approval.

Sourcing Funds for EB-5 Investment

Gathering funds for the EB-5 investment can be a significant task for Indian students and their families. Funds from selling real estate, such as land, apartments, or inherited property, can be used. Due to India’s foreign remittance limit of $250,000 per financial year under the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) guidelines, Indian investors often use partial investments to begin the EB-5 process.

Importance of Early Application

As an Indian student, you should consider applying for the EB-5 visa as early as possible. Thanks to the RIA, new reserved set-aside visa categories were created to avoid existing backlogs in the unreserved EB-5 category. The Department of State signaled in its January 2025 bulletin that it may soon impose cut-off dates for these set-aside categories to avoid exceeding visa limits. According to the latest Visa Bulletin, the unreserved EB-5 category for Indian applicants remains retrogressed, with the final action date of May 1, 2019. This means that Indian investors with priority dates after this cutoff are facing significant delays. Although the RIA-created reserved categories provide temporary relief, rising demand is expected to create new backlogs in those categories as well. This is especially true in the high-unemployment TEA category, which is already attracting high volumes of applications.

Professional Guidance

Applying for an EB-5 visa requires careful planning, accurate documentation, and guidance from experienced professionals. A qualified EB-5 immigration attorney plays a key role in this process, assisting in evaluating funding options while ensuring compliance with USCIS documentation requirements. Since the EB-5 process involves many steps, it is best to work with experienced EB-5 professionals to ensure a smooth journey. At EB5AN, we support Indian families through every step of this journey.

The Broader Impact of International Students

International students play a pivotal role in the United States, contributing over $43 billion annually to the economy and supporting 378,175 jobs across industries. In 2018 alone, they added roughly $41 billion, supporting thousands of jobs. In the 2023-24 academic year, international students' contributions neared $12 billion and supported over 65,000 jobs, according to NAFSA. Beyond their financial impact, these students enrich campus diversity and drive innovation in STEM, research, and other critical fields.

Economic Contributions

International students' economic contributions extend beyond tuition and living expenses. They often contribute to local economies through spending on goods and services, supporting businesses and creating jobs.

Innovation and Research

International students are heavily concentrated in STEM fields, driving innovation and research in these critical areas. Their presence enhances the quality of academic programs and contributes to the United States' global competitiveness.

Campus Diversity

International students enrich campus diversity, bringing diverse perspectives and experiences to classrooms and campus communities. This diversity fosters a more inclusive and globally aware learning environment.

The Role of Universities and Colleges

Universities are championing policies to protect and expand OPT and H1B visas, simplify green card pathways for international graduates, and advocate for streamlined immigration processes.

Supporting International Students

Many institutions are implementing programs and initiatives to support international students, including providing legal assistance, career counseling, and cultural integration services.

Advocacy for Policy Changes

Universities are actively advocating for policy changes that support international students, such as expanding OPT and H-1B visa programs and simplifying the green card process.

Perspectives on the Future

Perspectives on the future are not uniformly pessimistic. While some worry about the potential financial strain on higher education and a possible decline in campus diversity, others are more optimistic. Some Indian students and tech professionals feel hopeful about Trump’s return to office, seeing potential advantages in the strong relationship between Indian Prime Minister Modi and Trump. Some believe this rapport could give Indian tech workers an edge over immigrants from other countries. Furthermore, The Economic Times reported that the Trump administration could introduce policies aimed at lowering taxes, reducing regulations, and easing restrictions to stimulate business. Karthikeyan K, Director of Permanent Recruitment at Adecco, suggests that such policies could have a positive impact on India’s job market by creating opportunities in sectors like IT, pharmaceuticals, and manufacturing.

Optimism Amidst Uncertainty

Despite the potential challenges, many stakeholders remain optimistic about the future of international education in the United States. They believe that the country's strong academic institutions, diverse culture, and vibrant economy will continue to attract talented students from around the world.

The Importance of Vigilance

International students, and the institutions and companies that rely on them, must stay vigilant. At a time when global competition for talent is fiercer than ever, preserving pathways like OPT and STEM OPT isn’t just a kindness, it’s a strategic advantage.

tags: #Indian #students #OPT #unemployment #risk #factors