Navigating the Winds of Change: Understanding the NCAA Football Coaching Carousel
The landscape of college football coaching is in a perpetual state of flux, with the 2025-2026 season proving to be no exception to the dramatic shifts that characterize the sport. The recent head coaching carousel saw an unprecedented 34 openings across FBS from early September through February, with approximately half of these at Power Four programs. While the intensity of this past cycle might suggest a quieter period ahead, simmering discontent and pressure surround several established coaches within prominent programs, particularly at the lower echelons of the ACC and Big Ten. These coaches face the critical imperative to demonstrate significant improvement in the upcoming 2026 season to solidify confidence in their tenures.
The Florida State Crucible: Mike Norvell Under Scrutiny
One of the most intensely watched "hot seats" heading into the 2026 season is undoubtedly at Florida State. The Seminoles are embarking on the seventh year of a tenure under head coach Mike Norvell that has been marked by significant turbulence. Norvell's journey through the college coaching ranks spanned a decade, during which he honed his skills as a wide receivers coach, passing game coordinator, quarterbacks coach, and offensive coordinator. His career path included impactful stints at Central Arkansas, Tulsa, Pittsburgh, and Arizona State before he was named the successor to Justin Fuente at Memphis in the 2016 offseason.
At Memphis, Norvell orchestrated a remarkable four-year run, achieving no less than eight wins in each season. This impressive 38-15 record included notable victories over Power Four opponents such as Kansas, UCLA, and Ole Miss, establishing his credentials as a capable program builder. Florida State then recruited Norvell to take the helm as Willie Taggart's successor early in the 2020 offseason.
The initial challenge for Norvell at Florida State was monumental: rebuilding a program amidst the unprecedented disruption of a global pandemic. This difficult start was reflected in the Seminoles' 3-6 overall record in the 2020 season. Any nascent optimism for the 2021 season was severely dampened by an unexpected and demoralizing loss to Jacksonville State in the second week of the campaign.
Despite an initial 8-13 record, the situation at Florida State began to improve under Norvell. The Seminoles achieved a significant turnaround, winning six consecutive games to finish the 2022 season with a 10-3 record. Their trajectory was so strong that a key injury to quarterback Jordan Travis arguably prevented them from reaching the 2024 College Football Playoff. The period of 2022 and 2023 saw a combined 23-4 record, which largely quieted the external criticism surrounding Norvell. However, this calm was short-lived.
Read also: Anthony Robles: Overcoming Obstacles
The 2024 season proved to be a significant setback, with Florida State bottoming out at a 2-10 overall mark, their worst performance since 1974. While an opening-week victory against Alabama in the 2025 season offered a brief reprieve from the "hot seat" discussions, a subsequent 2-6 record in ACC play and an inability to achieve bowl eligibility after a loss at Florida reignited the intense scrutiny.
Now, with a career record of 38-34 at Florida State, the discourse surrounding Norvell's future has intensified. College football analyst Josh Pate prominently featured Norvell's situation at the top of his list of coaches facing must-win scenarios for the 2026 season. "Mike Norvell’s got to lead the list," Pate stated. "When you’re talking about must-win, like got to get it done in 2026, Mike Norvell and Florida State have to be at the top of the list. It seems the most obvious." The challenges ahead for Florida State in 2026 are formidable, with a non-conference schedule that once again features tough tests against Alabama and Florida. Furthermore, their ACC slate, while not overwhelmingly difficult, only includes Boston College as a team that finished with a losing record in 2025, underscoring the need for consistent performance within the conference.
The Coaching Carousel's Potential Targets: A Glimpse into Future Possibilities
Beyond the immediate pressure on Norvell, the broader landscape of college football coaching offers a fascinating array of potential candidates should openings arise. Several prominent names are frequently discussed, representing a mix of proven success, intriguing potential, and specific program fits.
Established Winners and Program Builders:
- James Franklin: A highly regarded figure known for his ability to build and sustain successful programs. His tenure at Penn State has been marked by consistent performance, though a perceived inability to consistently defeat Ohio State and Michigan has been a point of discussion. His availability, even if temporary, makes him a significant consideration for many programs.
- Jeff Brohm: A Louisville alum who has found success at his alma mater after a respectable stint at Purdue. His familiarity with the program and his winning record make him a seemingly ideal candidate for Louisville, though his availability for other openings remains uncertain.
- Lane Kiffin: Renowned for his offensive acumen and exceptional ability to navigate the transfer portal, Kiffin has demonstrated success at Ole Miss. His departure from Ole Miss, while messy, highlighted his adaptability and effectiveness in building competitive rosters. Programs like Florida and LSU have been cited as potential landing spots should their head coaching positions become available.
- Lincoln Riley: Despite rumors of potential unhappiness in Los Angeles, Riley has consistently fielded high-performing teams. His offensive systems are well-established, and his name is always in the conversation for elite openings, though his current situation suggests a possible desire for a change.
- Eli Drinkwitz: Currently at Missouri, Drinkwitz has shown an ability to win games consistently in the highly competitive SEC, even with perceived limitations in recruiting resources. His name is often linked with potential openings at programs like Florida and LSU.
Rising Stars and Intriguing Prospects:
- Marcus Freeman: While considered a "pipe dream" by some, Freeman's potential as a head coach is widely acknowledged. Rumors suggest he may face academic recruiting hurdles at Notre Dame, making him a name of interest for programs like Penn State. His ability to develop a program is seen as significant.
- Rhett Lashlee: Currently at SMU, Lashlee has a history of successful offensive coordination and is seen as a strong candidate for future opportunities. His connection to Gus Malzahn, who is on staff, offers a potential for seamless transitions. The possibility of a higher ceiling at a program like Florida State compared to SMU makes him an interesting long-term prospect.
- Manny Diaz: An alumnus with a strong defensive coaching background, Diaz has garnered attention for his ability to lead a defense and recruit effectively in Florida and South Georgia. He is considered a realistic option for some programs.
- Kenny Dillingham: Another alumnus returning to his alma mater, Dillingham's interest in a move back East is uncertain, but his connection to his former program makes him a noteworthy name.
- Dan Mullen: A coach with a proven track record of winning and significant recruiting experience in Florida, Mullen possesses the fundamental skills to succeed at a high level.
Emerging Candidates and Program-Specific Fits:
- Jon Sumrall: Having rapidly rebuilt Troy and then led Tulane to the brink of the College Football Playoff, Sumrall has emerged as a highly sought-after commodity. His ability to develop programs and his success in the Sun Belt have positioned him as a strong candidate for Power Four openings, including Florida.
- Alex Golesh: His impressive work at USF, often exceeding expectations with limited resources, has made him an attractive hire for programs seeking to elevate their standing, as seen with his move to Auburn.
- Kirby Moore: After a successful stint as an offensive coordinator in the SEC, Moore has taken on his first head coaching role at Washington State, indicating a rising profile in the coaching ranks.
- Will Stein: Hired by Kentucky after a successful tenure as Oregon's offensive coordinator, Stein represents the new wave of offensive minds making an impact in the sport.
- Jimmy Rogers: Taking over at Iowa State after leading Washington State, Rogers is part of the ongoing churn, with coaches moving between programs seeking new challenges and opportunities.
The Strategic Considerations Behind Coaching Changes
The decision to change a head coach is rarely made lightly and often involves complex strategic considerations, particularly concerning roster management and the NCAA's transfer portal rules. The timing of a coaching change can significantly impact a program's ability to retain existing talent and attract new players.
One critical factor influencing the timing of dismissals is the NCAA's transfer portal window. When a coach is fired, especially mid-season, players on the roster gain the ability to enter the transfer portal, potentially leading to significant roster attrition. This is a reality that athletic departments must carefully navigate. The ideal scenario for many programs, even when a coach is perceived as a "dead man walking," is to delay any official announcement until the end of the season. This strategy aims to provide the current coaching staff, or a designated interim, with the opportunity to retain key players.
Read also: Crafting Your NCAA Profile
Furthermore, if a program has a successor already identified but not yet announced, the end-of-season timing allows the new coach to begin building relationships with prospective recruits and current roster members. This proactive approach is crucial for retaining players who might otherwise explore other options. The potential retention of existing assistant coaches, such as offensive and defensive coordinators, can also play a vital role in this process, providing a sense of continuity and stability for the players.
Read also: The Return of College Football Gaming
tags: #ncaa #football #coaches #rumors #news
