Student Councils: Reality vs. Fiction

Student councils, found in many primary and secondary schools, are often portrayed in vastly different ways in reality and fiction. While the goal of a student council is to give students a voice and involve them in school affairs, the extent of their power and influence varies greatly. This article explores the role and authority of student councils, examining the discrepancies between their real-world functions and their often exaggerated depictions in fiction.

Real-World Student Councils: Limited Authority

In many educational systems, including American, Canadian, and British schools, the ultimate authority rests with the principal, faculty, and school administration. These individuals and bodies are responsible for the overall management and operation of the school, setting policies, and making decisions that affect the student body. Student councils, in this context, typically have an advisory role and limited decision-making power.

The primary function of a real-world student council is to represent the interests of the students and provide a platform for student input. They may be involved in organizing school events, such as charity fundraisers, school dances, and spirit weeks. They may also serve as a liaison between the student body and the school administration, conveying student concerns and suggestions.

However, the decisions made by student councils are often subject to the approval of the principal and faculty. Teachers and administrators retain the authority to overrule student council decisions and ensure that school policies are followed. The student council's power is further limited by the school district, state/provincial, and federal governments, which set the overall framework for education.

Student Councils in Fiction: Exaggerated Power

In contrast to their real-world counterparts, student councils in fiction are often depicted as wielding significant power and influence. In some fictional portrayals, student councils possess decision-making powers that surpass those of the board of directors, the PTA, and the faculty. They are portrayed as independent entities with the authority to create and enforce their own rules, often without oversight from school staff.

This exaggerated portrayal of student council power can be seen in various forms of media, including anime, manga, and live-action films. In these fictional settings, student council members may have unparalleled freedom to do as they please on campus, invent arbitrary rules that restrict and punish the masses, and give themselves and their allies special privileges. Staff members may be conspicuously absent or unwilling to challenge the student council's authority.

One common trope in fiction is the "Absurdly Powerful Student Council," where the student council's authority extends beyond the school grounds and into the surrounding community. In some cases, the student council may even have the power to annex other schools or control the local economy.

Japanese Student Councils: A Grain of Truth

The exaggerated portrayal of student council power in fiction is often inspired by the role of student councils in Japanese schools. In Japan, student councils have some authority over the approval and funding of student clubs. School clubs are considered an important part of the educational experience, providing students with opportunities to develop their interests, build social skills, and prepare for the workforce.

The student council's control over club funding and activities gives them a degree of influence over student life. Clubs are highly encouraged as preparation for the work environment, and students are expected to stick with a single club until graduation. The student council decides whether a club gets to do anything, or even keep existing.

However, even in Japan, the power of student councils is not absolute. School administrators and teachers still retain ultimate authority over school affairs. The student council's role is primarily to facilitate student activities and promote a positive school environment.

Read also: Guide to UC Davis Student Housing

Examples in Media

Numerous examples in various media illustrate the spectrum of student council portrayals, from realistic to wildly exaggerated.

Anime and Manga

Angel Beats!: The Student Council represents subordinates of the Creator of said world. One of the female lead actually forms a rival organization to battle said student council.
Anime-Gataris: The student council is shown to be always looking to take down the little anime club to the point they can on a whim order their disbandment or demand they prove their worth.
Best Student Council: The eponymous student council has military, law enforcement, and intelligence/ninja divisions, and is hand-picked by its president.
Cardfight!! Vanguard: The Miyagi Academy High-school division student council has the power to approve the formation of school clubs.
Code Geass: Ashford Academy's Student Council President subjects the average students to her playful whims like Complete Silence Parties and the Crossdressing Festival.
Cute High Earth Defense Club LOVE!: The Student Council shuts down school clubs at seemingly random and has hefty privileges.
Kill la Kill: Honnouji's student council has created a straight-up fascist state and has the power to annex other schools and execute students.
Kujibiki♡Unbalance: The entire premise of the show consists of a group of students trying to become this.
Medaka Box: The student council goes up to eleven on the scale: powerful, capable of defeating any number of delinquents without effort, trained in ridiculously high levels of martial arts, and seemingly impervious to any school authority.
Student Council's Discretion: The premise of the anime is that a high school’s student council is selected by popularity vote for 4 of the members, and the 5th member is the student with the highest grades.

Live-Action Films and Television

Election: The story itself makes it clear that the Student Council does not have that much power, and that the whole process is largely a waste of time that much of the student body couldn't care less about.
Veronica Mars: An entire episode revolves around the corrupt antics of Neptune High's student council, which conceives a policy called "Pirate Points" to allow councilmen and their cronies on the various sports and cheer teams to have take-out food delivered to the school for them to eat, while forcing the rest of the students to eat the crappy cafeteria food.
School Ties: The teachers tell the students to form their own impromptu hearing to decide which one of them was cheating.

Other Examples

Boys Over Flowers: The student council consists of 4 self-proclaimed gods of the school who pay off the school to allow them to get away with ANYTHING, including publicly humiliating students they don't like.
Dance in the Vampire Bund: Mina founded the school and takes it over, much to the anger of the current student council president.
Fruits Basket: The council that Yuki ends up becoming president of doesn't seem to be especially powerful.
Girls und Panzer: The student council not only control the schools' funding but negotiate on an equal level with the national education authorities and can threaten to expel our heroine, Miho, for not taking up tankery as her elective.
Hana-Kimi: The student heads of the three school dormitories have the combined power to veto a school authority's decision.
Infinite Ryvius: Justified.
My-HiME: The student council essentially polices itself, with its actual headmaster being little more than a figurehead.
Revolutionary Girl Utena: The members of the Student Council have a private lift to their secret garden terrace where they debate the form the apocalypse will take based on the letters they all receive from The End Of The World.
Sket Dance: The student council executives are made to be celebrities, and their respective quirks are often played for laughs.
Strawberry Panic!: The student councils and their goings-on are given a great deal of ceremony, and the members are treated like royalty.

The Illusion of Power

The exaggerated portrayal of student council power in fiction serves various purposes. It can be used for comedic effect, creating situations where students wield authority in absurd and unexpected ways. It can also be used to explore themes of corruption, abuse of power, and the struggle for control.

However, it is important to remember that these fictional portrayals are not representative of the reality of student councils in most schools. While student councils can play a valuable role in promoting student voice and involvement, their power is typically limited and subject to the oversight of school administrators and teachers.

The creation of student councils is often intended to give students the illusion of having a say in their lives at school. In reality, the power dynamics within a school are complex, and students are not always given the opportunity to participate in meaningful decision-making.

The Importance of Student Voice

Despite the limitations of student council power, it is important to recognize the value of student voice in education. When students are given the opportunity to express their opinions and participate in school affairs, they feel more engaged and invested in their education.

Read also: Investigating the Death at Purdue

Student councils can provide a platform for students to develop leadership skills, learn about civic engagement, and advocate for their interests. They can also serve as a valuable resource for school administrators, providing insights into student perspectives and helping to create a more positive and inclusive school environment.

tags: #student #councils #discretion #powers