The Sword and The Sophomore: A Critical Summary
Every once in a while, a work of art emerges within the fantasy genre, captivating readers with its originality and compelling storytelling. However, not all attempts at fantasy fiction achieve such heights. "The Sword and The Sophomore" by B.P. Sweany, the first book in the "American Martyr Trilogy," presents a unique blend of Arthurian legend and young adult urban fantasy, but ultimately falls short of its potential.
Initial Impressions and Synopsis
At first glance, "The Sword and The Sophomore" promises a fresh take on familiar tropes. The synopsis is intriguing: Arlynn Rosemary Banson, a seemingly ordinary sixteen-year-old, discovers that she is descended from King Arthur and destined for a pivotal role in a mystical battle.
Rosemary is an atypical sixteen-year-old-the cool, popular outsider, effortlessly straddling the line between divas and dorks. Her forever young mother, Jennifer, is dedicated to making her life awkward by trying to be her friend. Her father, Alan, is a workaholic history professor who barely acknowledges his family’s existence. Her boyfriend, Benz, the quarterback and homecoming king, has just broken up with her, while her best friend, Joslin, bears reluctant witness to Rosemary’s romantic drama. But nothing prepares any of them for a Welsh foreign exchange student named Emrys Balin. Emrys looks like a teenager, but he seems to act much, much older. Rosemary discovers she is part of the Lust Borne Tide, children born to the royal line of King Uther Pendragon who are imbued with mystical powers after being conceived in lust. Rosemary’s parents are Guinevere and Lancelot, banished by King Arthur to twenty-first century suburban America prior to Rosemary’s birth as punishment for their affair. Rosemary is the third in the Lust Borne line, after King Arthur and his son Mordred, the latter of whom has traveled to the future to continue the line of the Lust Born Tide by retrieving Rosemary and returning her to the late fifth century to conceive a child with her. But Rosemary has other plans-plans that involve training under Emrys and kicking Mordred’s butt, as long as it doesn’t interfere with prom or getting back with her boyfriend Benz.
The blending of Arthurian elements with a contemporary high school setting holds promise, but the execution struggles to deliver a cohesive and compelling narrative.
Plot and Pacing Issues
One of the primary criticisms of "The Sword and The Sophomore" lies in its uneven pacing and unfocused plot. The story meanders through various side issues that often fail to contribute meaningfully to the central conflict. The climax, a crucial element in any narrative, arrives late in the book, leaving the reader feeling as though the story is rushed and underdeveloped.
Read also: What is a Rising Sophomore?
The story was strong and I was definitely interested in the ending as the story went on. I felt like the characters were well developed and overall it was a decent story. However, I wasn't that pleased with this book. I feel like most of the story wasn't focused on the plot but rather on random side issues that didn't even come into the plot later. The climax of the story came about 85% into the book. The pacing was off throughout the read and it felt more like a first draft than a nearly finished read. I found myself wondering what the point of the chapters were multiple times throughout the book and I definitely think it could have been a smaller story given what was plot relevant in it.
The narrative's diversions distract from the core storyline, creating a sense of disjointedness that prevents the reader from fully engaging with the main plot. This lack of focus diminishes the overall impact of the story and leaves the reader questioning the relevance of certain chapters and subplots.
Character Development
While the characters in "The Sword and The Sophomore" possess a certain charm, their development is hampered by the story's structural issues. Rosemary, the protagonist, is described as funny and sassy, but at times comes across as cringey. Her preoccupation with boy drama detracts from her potential as a strong, superhuman character.
She was funny and sassy but cringy at times. The drama over the Benz was way too much for me. She worries about him, and how she will get him back is a significant flaw. She is superhuman, strong, and fast but is too concerned with the boy drama. It makes her character seem flimsy and lacking depth. Not all girls spend every waking moment thinking about boys.
The emphasis on romantic entanglements overshadows Rosemary's development as a powerful figure destined to confront Mordred. This imbalance weakens her character arc and prevents her from fully realizing her potential.
Read also: "Sophomore": A word's journey through time
World-Building and Magic System
The introduction of the Lust Borne Tide and the mystical powers associated with it offers an intriguing element of world-building. However, the execution of this concept raises concerns. The fact that Rosemary's powers become fully realized only after puberty and losing her virginity is a questionable narrative choice that detracts from the story's overall appeal.
Also, I wouldn't say I liked the fact that her powers became fully realized until puberty and losing her virginity. It honestly made me want to put the book down.
This plot device feels contrived and unnecessary, undermining the potential for a more nuanced exploration of Rosemary's powers and her connection to the Arthurian lineage.
Overall Assessment
"The Sword and The Sophomore" presents an interesting premise, blending Arthurian legend with contemporary young adult themes. However, the novel suffers from pacing issues, a lack of focus, and questionable character development choices. While the story holds moments of promise, it ultimately falls short of delivering a cohesive and compelling narrative.
Themes and Connections to Other Works
The novel touches on themes of destiny, identity, and the challenges of adolescence. Rosemary's journey of self-discovery mirrors the experiences of many young adults as they grapple with their place in the world and their potential for greatness.
Read also: Freshman to Senior: A Guide
The Arthurian elements of the story invite comparisons to other works that reimagine the legend, such as Mary Stewart's "The Crystal Cave" and T.H. White's "The Once and Future King." However, "The Sword and The Sophomore" lacks the depth and complexity of these classic retellings.
Target Audience and Potential Appeal
Despite its flaws, "The Sword and The Sophomore" may appeal to young adult readers who enjoy urban fantasy and stories with a strong female protagonist. The novel's blend of action, romance, and mythology could attract readers looking for a light and entertaining read.
However, readers seeking a more sophisticated and nuanced exploration of Arthurian themes may find the novel lacking.
tags: #the #sword #and #the #sophomore #summary
